United States v. Nemeth
Split Score
What is a Split Score?
This score (0-100) indicates how likely this case is to be reviewed by the Supreme Court based on:
Case Summary
Disposition
Affirmed
The Tenth Circuit affirmed the denial of James Nemeth’s motions to suppress drug-evidence obtained after a narcotics-dog sniff at his motel-room door and to dismiss his firearm indictment under § 922(g)(1). The panel held that Nemeth waived his core Fourth-Amendment argument and that his Second-Amendment challenge is foreclosed by circuit precedent, thus leaving the convictions intact.
Circuit Split Identified
Legal Issue
Whether a drug-detection dog sniff at the doorway of a dwelling (apartment or motel room) constitutes a Fourth-Amendment "search" because it intrudes on a reasonable expectation of privacy inside the residence.
Circuit Positions
Dog sniff at the door of a dwelling is a search violating the resident’s reasonable expectation of privacy.
Dog sniff at the door of a dwelling is not a search; Caballes categorical rule applies.
Issue not decided; court declined to reach merits due to waiver under Rule 12.
Conflict Summary
The Seventh and Second Circuits treat a doorway dog sniff as a search that invades the resident’s privacy interest inside the dwelling, while the Fourth and Eighth Circuits apply a categorical rule from Caballes/Place that dog sniffs are never searches because they reveal only contraband. The Tenth Circuit in this case expressly declined to decide the question, treating it as waived, and thus took no substantive position.