Circuit Split Alerter

Stay informed about federal circuit court conflicts that shape American law

What are Circuit Splits?

Circuit splits occur when different Federal Circuit Courts reach conflicting decisions on similar legal questions. These conflicts often signal cases ripe for Supreme Court review.

How We Help

Our system automatically monitors Federal Circuit Court opinions, identifies potential splits using AI analysis, and alerts legal professionals to important developments.

Sign up for daily email alerts

Recent Circuit Splits
USA v. Antonio Brown
SplitScore: 69/100

Legal Issue:

Whether a robbery defendant who merely brandishes a firearm and orders victims to comply thereby "physically restrains" them for purposes of the two-level enhancement in U.S.S.G. § 2B3.1(b)(4)(B).
Oct 8, 2026Circuit 11Circuit 1Circuit 4Circuit 6Circuit 10conflicting withCircuit 2Circuit 3Circuit 5Circuit 7Circuit 9
Celis-Nino, et al. v. Blanche
SplitScore: 60/100

Legal Issue:

Whether the 30-day petition-for-review filing deadline in 8 U.S.C. § 1252(b)(1), now deemed a non-jurisdictional claim-processing rule after Riley v. Bondi, is subject to equitable tolling.
Oct 7, 2026Circuit 10conflicting withCircuit 4Circuit 6Circuit 7conflicting withCircuit 5Circuit 8
Sandoz Inc v. United Therapeutics Corporation
SplitScore: 38/100

Legal Issue:

Whether, under Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 28(i), a party that adopts sections of a co-party’s appellate brief must count those adopted words toward the word-limit set by Rule 28.1(e).
Oct 7, 2026Circuit 3Circuit 8Circuit 10conflicting with
Curtrina Martin, et al v. USA, et al
SplitScore: 75/100

Legal Issue:

Whether the Federal Tort Claims Act's discretionary-function exception shields the United States from liability when the challenged conduct is merely careless/negligent rather than a conscious policy judgment.
Oct 7, 2026Circuit 11Circuit 8Circuit 9Circuit 10conflicting withCircuit 2Circuit 4Circuit 7
Sophia Wilansky v. Morton County
SplitScore: 42/100

Legal Issue:

Whether 28 U.S.C. § 1920(4) allows a prevailing party to tax e-discovery costs that go beyond scanning or file-format conversion (e.g., costs for collecting, preserving, processing, hosting, indexing, and extracting electronically stored information).
Oct 5, 2026Circuit 8conflicting withCircuit 3Circuit 4Circuit 11Federal Circuit
William Fambrough v. City of E. Cleveland, Ohio -Northern District of Ohio at Cleveland
SplitScore: 47/100

Legal Issue:

Whether the Fourth Amendment's 'community-caretaking' exception requires police to follow standardized criteria when deciding to impound a vehicle (as is required for post-impound inventory searches).
Oct 1, 2026Circuit 6conflicting withCircuit 1Circuit 3Circuit 5
Torres-Roldan, et al. v. Blanche
SplitScore: 63/100

Legal Issue:

Whether a non-citizen must demonstrate prejudice when an Immigration Judge fails to comply with 8 C.F.R. § 1240.10(a)(1)’s requirement to ask if the respondent desires counsel.
Oct 1, 2026Circuit 10conflicting withCircuit 2Circuit 3conflicting withCircuit 4Circuit 5
SWN Production Co LLC v. Blue Beck Ltd
SplitScore: 74/100

Legal Issue:

Whether a federal district court that has dismissed a case for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction may nevertheless entertain and award attorney’s fees under a fee-shifting provision.
Sep 29, 2026Circuit 3Circuit 2Circuit 5Circuit 6Circuit 8Circuit 9Circuit 11conflicting withCircuit 7Circuit 10
KalshiEX LLC v. Matthew Schuler -Southern District of Ohio at Columbus
SplitScore: 57/100

Legal Issue:

Whether sports-event contracts offered on federally regulated designated contract markets are “swaps” under 7 U.S.C. §1a(47) such that the CEA grants the CFTC exclusive jurisdiction and pre-empts state sports-gambling laws.
Sep 25, 2026Circuit 6Circuit 9conflicting withCircuit 3
USA v. Kevan Carter Gibbs, II
SplitScore: 53/100

Legal Issue:

Whether law-enforcement officers may, without a new warrant, open and examine digital files referenced in a NCMEC CyberTip under the private-search doctrine.
Sep 17, 2026Circuit 11conflicting withCircuit 5Circuit 6conflicting withCircuit 2Circuit 9
US v. Levasseur
SplitScore: 91/100

Legal Issue:

Whether individuals with felony convictions are within "the people" protected by the Second Amendment and therefore may invoke Second-Amendment rights against 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1).
Sep 16, 2026Circuit 1conflicting withCircuit 2Circuit 3Circuit 5Circuit 6Circuit 7Circuit 9Circuit 10conflicting withCircuit 4
Kyle Beatty v. Clinton Gardner
SplitScore: 83/100

Legal Issue:

Whether a warrant supported by probable cause is required to conduct a strip search of an arrestee outside the jail/prison context, or whether reasonable suspicion suffices under the Fourth Amendment’s search-incident-to-arrest doctrine.
Sep 16, 2026Circuit 3Circuit 5Circuit 9Circuit 10conflicting withCircuit 1Circuit 7Circuit 8Circuit 11
Kindra O''Bryant v. DCP&P
SplitScore: 64/100

Legal Issue:

What constitutional standard governs an emergency, pre-hearing removal of children from parental custody by child-protective authorities?
Sep 16, 2026Circuit 3conflicting withCircuit 2Circuit 9Circuit 10conflicting withCircuit 1conflicting withCircuit 5
United States v. Chance York -Northern District of Ohio at Akron
SplitScore: 54/100

Legal Issue:

How to count videos as “images” under U.S.S.G. § 2G2.2(b)(7) when determining the number-of-images enhancement for child-pornography offenses.
Sep 14, 2026Circuit 6conflicting withCircuit 3Circuit 11
US v. Pena de la Cruz
SplitScore: 56/100

Legal Issue:

Standard for when a court may deny a Rule 48(a) motion or dismiss an indictment with prejudice – whether discretion is limited to prosecutorial bad-faith/harassment (or other patent unfairness to the defendant) or may rest on broader ‘public-interest’ and ‘integrity of the courts’ considerations.
Sep 11, 2026Circuit 1Circuit 4Circuit 5Circuit 8conflicting withCircuit 10