B.B. V. CAPISTRANO UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT, ET AL.
Split Score
What is a Split Score?
This score (0-100) indicates how likely this case is to be reviewed by the Supreme Court based on:
Case Summary
Disposition
Vacated
The Ninth Circuit held that elementary-school students have First Amendment protection for their expressive works and that the Tinker student-speech framework applies in the elementary context. Finding genuine factual disputes about whether the principal reasonably believed a first-grader’s drawing invaded another student’s rights, the court vacated the district court’s summary judgment for the defendants and remanded for further proceedings.
Circuit Split Identified
Legal Issue
Scope of Tinker’s “interference with the rights of others” prong—whether schools may restrict student speech that is derogatory toward a protected class even when the speech would not give rise to traditional tort liability.
Circuit Positions
Tinker’s second prong permits schools to restrict student speech that targets or denigrates other students’ protected characteristics even if such speech would not be independently tortious.
Tinker’s second prong allows regulation only of student speech that would subject the school to tort liability (defamation, invasion of privacy, etc.); mere derogatory remarks are insufficient.
Conflict Summary
The Ninth Circuit (joining the 6th, 7th, 3rd, and 5th Circuits) interprets Tinker broadly, allowing regulation of student speech that denigrates a student’s core identifying characteristic (race, religion, sexual orientation, etc.) because such speech invades the target’s right to be ‘secure and let alone.’ The Eighth Circuit, in Hazelwood Sch. Dist. v. Kuhlmeier, 795 F.2d 1368 (8th Cir. 1986), had read Tinker’s second prong narrowly, limiting school regulation to speech that could expose the school to tort liability (defamation, invasion of privacy, etc.). The current opinion expressly rejects the Eighth Circuit’s narrower construction, creating a direct disagreement on the reach of Tinker’s second prong.