Pomeroy v. Utah State Bar, et al.
Split Score
What is a Split Score?
This score (0-100) indicates how likely this case is to be reviewed by the Supreme Court based on:
Case Summary
Disposition
Affirmed
The Tenth Circuit rejected attorney Amy Pomeroy’s First-Amendment challenge to Utah’s mandatory bar-membership and dues requirements. Relying on Keller and its own precedent in Schell, the court held that the Utah State Bar’s challenged lobbying, journal, and social-media activities were either germane to regulating the legal profession or, in the lone arguably non-germane instance, too minimal to matter, and that the Bar’s refund and objection procedures were constitutionally adequate. Accordingly, the panel affirmed the district court’s dismissal and summary judgment for the Bar.
Circuit Split Identified
Legal Issue
Whether compelled membership in an integrated (mandatory) state bar violates the First Amendment whenever the bar engages in any non-germane political or ideological activity, or only when such activity is substantial enough to be attributed to the bar’s members.
Circuit Positions
Any non-germane activity by a mandatory state bar necessarily violates the First Amendment; compelled membership fails exacting scrutiny.
Compelled membership remains constitutional so long as non-germane activity is minimal or not reasonably attributed to members; no automatic violation.
Question left open; Tenth Circuit acknowledges split and reserves deciding whether any non-germane activity automatically renders compelled membership unconstitutional.
Conflict Summary
The Fifth Circuit holds that any non-germane activity by an integrated bar necessarily fails exacting scrutiny and therefore makes compulsory membership unconstitutional. The Ninth Circuit disagrees, concluding that minor or non-expressive non-germane activity does not automatically create a First-Amendment violation if the public would not associate the speech with individual bar members. The Tenth Circuit, in this opinion, expressly notes the split but declines to choose a side, leaving the question open.